Here’s a pattern I keep running into in executive search. A search firm contacts a client for one of two reasons. Either a live search needs something, or the firm would like the next one.
In between, things go quiet. And when every message that does arrive is a request, the client learns to read the next one as a request before they’ve opened it. It’s the reflex a homeowner develops with envelopes from the county. Nobody has to open one to know it’s probably a bill.
That’s my observation, not a survey finding. But if you’ve ever watched a perfectly warm client take a week to answer a friendly check-in, you’ll recognize it.
From the client’s side, that’s sensible triage. The trouble is what it does to you. By the time there’s a mandate worth discussing, your name’s already filed under “wants something.”
A recurring market digest is one way to stay in touch without asking for anything. I’ve written before about the general case for partners publishing their thinking, so I won’t repeat it here. This piece is about what goes inside a monthly digest and, just as usefully, what stays out.
One firm’s version of the format
Lunar Executive Search has published The Modern GTM Executive, a newsletter written by Joey Brodsky for sales, marketing, and executive leaders at growth-stage technology businesses. Its archive shows weekly issues through mid-August 2026, on subjects like reading jobs reports, negotiating executive compensation, and AI-related hiring.
On August 17, 2026, Brodsky sent an update saying the newsletter was going “under construction” for a few weeks to refresh its design and calibrate both its weekly content and the data and research behind it. He asked readers to reply with two things. The first was what they’d enjoyed or wanted more of, with options that included GTM hiring market data, market trend or sentiment breakdowns, tactical how-to content, and job opportunities. The second was what the newsletter had missed entirely.
What this shows is a search firm running an established publication for a defined leadership audience, and asking that audience directly which market information it values. What it doesn’t show is that the newsletter generates mandates. Nothing in the update claims that, and I won’t either.
One difference up front. Lunar’s readers include executives who are potential candidates, which is why job opportunities sit on that list of options. The digest I’m describing is written for hiring clients. Lunar’s cadence has typically been weekly. However, the method below uses a monthly cadence, which is a smaller commitment for a boutique firm and leaves time for a partner to interpret each issue.
Build each issue around one hiring question
A digest that rounds up “this month in the market” has no test for what goes in. So it grows to fit whatever got published that month. It’s grocery shopping without a list. You come home with whatever was stacked at the end of the aisle.
I understand why firms default to the roundup. It’s easy to fill, and it never forces anyone to decide what the issue is actually about.
A digest built around one hiring question does have a test. Every candidate item either helps the reader answer the question or it doesn’t.
The right question is one your clients are likely to face in the next quarter, phrased the way a CEO, board member, or CHRO would phrase it in a meeting. “What’s happening with CFO compensation?” is a topic. “If our CFO leaves this year, should we expect to pay more than their current package to replace them?” is a question a board would actually ask. And it tells you straight away which items belong.
The partner picks it, because they’re the one hearing which questions clients are raising right now.
What earns a place
Once the issue question is set, these are the four tests I put every candidate item through:
- It relates to the issue’s hiring question.
- It links to a primary source, so the reader can check it.
- The partner can say what it means for a hiring decision, beyond restating it.
- The reader could act on it this quarter.
That list is my method, not something a study has tested.
Test 3 does most of the work. Say a new report on executive turnover comes out. It fits the question, and it links to its source. If all the partner can do is repeat the headline, it’s a news link, and the reader learns nothing the press release wouldn’t have told them. If the partner can say which client situations the finding applies to, and which it doesn’t, the item passes. That one sentence is the reason it belongs in a search firm’s digest at all.
One or two news links in an issue are fine. An issue made entirely of them is a clipping service. Your clients already have one of those. It’s called their inbox.
Hypothetical example: an annotated issue
The firm, issue, and items below are invented to show the four tests in use. There are no figures, because none of them would be real.
Firm: Farnhill Partners, a boutique retained search firm working with private equity-backed software companies.
Issue question: “When a portfolio company replaces its CEO, which leadership roles should the board expect to revisit in the following year?”
Lead read (300 to 400 words). The partner picks one relevant development, say a recently published study of CEO succession drawn from public filings, links to the original and says what it measures and what it doesn’t. Annotation: the lead read stays inside the study’s own sample. It doesn’t stretch a public-company study to cover private equity-backed companies without saying so. Test 2 only works if a reader who clicks through finds what the partner said they’d find.
Short items (three, 40 to 60 words each). Each one links to a primary source: a regulatory filing, a published survey with its sample stated, or a company announcement. Annotation: each item gets one sentence connecting it to the issue question. An item that needs a second paragraph to justify being there fails test 1 for this issue. Save it for another.
Partner’s interpretation (100 to 150 words), marked as opinion. The partner states a view on the issue question drawn from their own assignments, without identifying clients or candidates. Annotation: this is test 3 at full length. It’s also the part a news service or a competitor can’t reproduce, because it comes from searches only this partner has run.
One thing to do. A question the reader can take into their next leadership or board meeting, or a figure to check in their own data. Annotation: this is test 4. The issue ends with something the reader can use. Not a request for a meeting.
What belongs elsewhere
Some content is perfectly reasonable for a search firm to publish and still weakens a client-facing digest, because it turns the digest back into a message that wants something from the reader. Which is the exact pattern the digest was meant to get you out of.
Open roles and candidate solicitations. These suit a readership of potential candidates, which is part of Lunar’s audience, so they’re a sensible choice for Lunar. A digest for hiring clients is a different publication. Open roles belong in candidate-facing channels, or in a clearly separate section if your list really does serve both groups.
Firm announcements and placement news. I know the temptation. A strong placement is the most concrete proof you’ve got, and the digest is sitting right there with an audience already opted in. But a placement announcement is promotional, and it changes how the reader classifies the whole message. Send it on its own, to the clients it’s actually relevant to.
When did a newsletter that opened with the sender’s good news last keep you reading to the bottom?
US law draws a similar line. Under the FTC’s CAN-SPAM rule, an email that mixes promotional content with other content is treated as commercial in either of two cases. The first is if a recipient reasonably interpreting the subject line would likely conclude the message contains promotion. The second is if a recipient reasonably interpreting the body would likely conclude that promotion is its primary purpose. The factors the rule lists for reading the body include whether the promotional content is placed at the beginning and what proportion of the message it takes up. A digest that opens with your latest placement has already moved toward that line on placement, and further if the announcement fills much of the issue. The FTC also states that the law “makes no exception for business-to-business email.” Being treated as commercial doesn’t make a message illegal. It means the Act’s requirements apply, including a working opt-out and your physical postal address.
My read is that promotional drift changes a digest’s character for the reader, and possibly its legal treatment too. That’s my application of the rule, not legal advice. And CAN-SPAM is a US law. If your firm is based somewhere else, or your list reaches clients in other countries, the rules there may draw this line in the same place or somewhere quite different. So look into what applies in each country you send to, ideally with counsel, before the first issue goes out.
Long-form argument. A full essay on a single position belongs in your articles. The digest can link to it.
Anything drawn from a live or recent search. Your interpretation can be informed by assignments. Details that could identify a client or candidate don’t belong in a mailing, however well you think you’ve disguised them.
Ask the readers
Lunar’s August update hands you a practical method: ask readers, by reply, what they want more of and what’s missing. Repeat it every so often, with concrete options, the way Lunar offered them, so a reader can answer in one line between meetings.
The answers tell you which issue questions to pick next. They aren’t a measure of commercial results. A flattering reply isn’t a pipeline.
What the digest is for
Subscriber counts and open rates tell you how far the publication reaches. They don’t establish that the digest generates mandates, and you shouldn’t report them as if they did.
What the digest does give you is the thing that opening pattern was missing: a regular reason to contact clients between searches, one that asks nothing of them and carries an interpretation the partner has put their name to. If you want the format without the production load, you can commission a monthly market digest built on the structure above.
A Market Digests engagement starts with the issue question and the partner’s time, not with a template of links. Over a year, a monthly digest is twelve envelopes from you that a client can open without first wondering what’s being asked of them.



Leave a Reply